
The Best Leaders Know When to Leave
The Best Leaders Know When to Leave
Lessons from lambs
"Six new lambs!”
That’s the text from Amy that wakes me up.
“Gonna get a cup of coffee and come back in 30 minutes."
My brain’s not fully online and so I’m confused as to why she’s leaving the minutes-old babies.
Actually, my confusion has nothing to do with my circadian rhythm. It’s rooted in why someone with a degree in Animal Sciences abandons newborns to fend for themselves.
Leaving rookies at the very moment they need you most? That’s counter to everything I learned in 30 years wearing the Air Force uniform.
But as a lifelong learner, I realize Amy is teaching me something about leadership by walking away from six newborn animals.
Let me explain.
Amy walks into the barn this morning. Six brand-new lambs, still wet, still figuring out that whole "standing" thing. Their mothers, some first-time moms, some old pros, are doing what new moms do.
Licking. Nudging. Making those low bleating sounds that say, “This one's mine.”
It's nature doing what nature's been doing for millennia (and doing pretty well, considering sheep are still here despite their questionable survival instincts).
Then Amy appears.
And every single ewe abandons their lamb and runs toward her.
Because Amy means grain. Amy means food. Amy means the good stuff that makes their sheep brains very, very happy.
And suddenly six newborns are alone, mothers nowhere in sight, that critical bonding window ticking away like a countdown timer nobody can see.
So Amy does the hardest thing a shepherd can do.
She leaves.
Here's what the research says (because of course I Googled sheep bonding at 7 AM like a completely normal person):
Ewes form bonds with their lambs within 30 minutes after birth. That's the window. If a ewe can't interact with her lamb during this time, she might reject it entirely.
Thirty minutes to learn the smell, the sound, the specific bleat that says, “Dibs on this one” (which, I’m told, sounds different from the bleat for, “I’m hungry” and “I stubbed my hoof”).
After that window closes, the ewe knows her lamb from every other lamb in the flock. She'll reject strangers. She'll only let her own baby nurse.
But here's the kicker: human presence during this time can suppress the whole process. Fear of humans interferes with maternal instinct. Our well-meaning intervention, just checking, just making sure everyone's okay, can derail the entire system (which feels like a metaphor for every leadership workshop I've ever taught, but I digress).
The best thing Amy can do for those lambs is walk away.
Trust that the ewes know what they're doing.
I spend most of my professional life telling leaders the opposite.
Stay engaged. Stay present. Check in regularly. Don't disappear on your team.
And I stand by all of that.
But.
There's a moment - and this is the part nobody puts in leadership books - where the best thing a leader can do is get the hell out of the way.
Not because you don't care.
Because you care so much that you're willing to let people figure it out themselves.
Think about the last time you hovered over someone's shoulder.
Maybe it was a new hire working on their first project.
Maybe it was a team member tackling something slightly outside their comfort zone.
Maybe it was your kid learning to tie their shoes (or in my case, watching Jen plant the garden while I repeatedly asked if she was sure that's where the tomatoes should go).
You knew you can do it faster. Better. More efficiently.
You knew exactly where they were going to struggle.
You could see the mistake coming from a mile away.
And every fiber of your being wants to step in and fix it before they even make the error.
But here's what happens when you do:
They stop trusting their own judgment.
They stop trying to solve problems independently.
They become dependent on you for guidance, constantly turning to you because they've been conditioned to think they need it.
You've trained them that their instincts can't be trusted.
Just like those ewes running toward Amy instead of staying with their newborns.
The tricky (and messy) part is knowing which moment you're in.
Sometimes people need you to stay. Sometimes intervention is exactly what's required.
A first-time mom struggling with a difficult birth? Yeah, Amy doesn't walk away from that. She jumps in, helps, makes sure both mom and baby survive.
But six healthy lambs with three healthy moms who just need thirty minutes of uninterrupted bonding time?
Walking away isn't abandonment.
It's trust.
I'm thinking about this at my desk today because I’m working with a client who is the human embodiment of this exact problem.
Smart leader. Capable team. But he couldn’t stop checking in, couldn’t stop "just making sure," couldn’t stop hovering over every decision like those thirty minutes of bonding time weren’t real.
His team keeps running toward him instead of toward the work.
Because he's the grain.
He's the attractive distraction that feels safer than trusting their own instincts.
And the more he stays involved, the more they believe they can't do it without him.
Amy's back in the barn now.
Six lambs. All nursing. All bonded.
The ewes ignore her this time. They've got more important things to do.
Nature figured it out.
Just like she knew it would.
So here's what I'm sitting with today:
What if the best leadership move isn't always stepping in?
What if sometimes it's stepping back?
What if the highest form of trust isn't "I believe you'll do it my way” - it’s "I believe you'll figure it out"?
The ewes didn't need Amy's supervision.
They needed her absence. They needed space to do what they already knew how to do, deep in their DNA, if we'd just stop distracting them with grain.
Your team might need the same thing.
Not because you're a bad leader.
Because you're good enough to know when to leave.
Six new lambs.
And one old lesson I keep forgetting:
Sometimes the bravest thing a leader can do is walk out of the barn.